Jean Georges (NYC) – Bombastic Fantastic

Memories can often conspire against one’s enjoyment of food. My last Jean Georges meal did not remind me of that glorious dinner six years ago. However, the pricing for lunch 1 is too cheap not to try it again. On its own terms. I changed my approach with this visit. The flavors would not be subtle; instead, they would be bombastic. I would accept that and eat the meal from that perspective. 2

The Wandering Eater recently ate at Jean Georges and her meal is similar to my report below. The dishes don’t change much so older reports can be just as reliable when planning.

The amuse bouches, Sunchoke & Cranberry, Shitake, and Salmon Belly, laid the blueprint for the meal – sharp tastes with an emphasis on textures.

Santa Barbara Sea Urchin, Black Bread, Jalapeno, and Yuzu began the meal with a forceful punch. The flavors were intense, seemingly bouncing around without concern for integration, but they melded together with each bite. The yuzu and jalapeno took turns dominating the tastes but both gave way to the urchin’s lasting sea flavor at the end. As jarring as the tastes, the textures of the dish played as prominent of a role – the crisp jalapeno, the transformation of the bread as you chew it, and the pervasive creamy uni. Very Good.

Sea Trout Sashimi Draped in Trout Eggs, Lemon, Dill, and Horseradish continued the full-blown taste and texture themes. The sequence of silky fish, popping fish eggs, and (I believe) crunchy skin lit up your mouth as much as the powerful tastes. And powerful they were. Blindly sticking your fork into the bowl would yield a completely unbalanced proportion of horseradish to lemon. After experimenting and adjusting, a powerful, but balanced, combination emerged where each ingredient managed to complement each other. Very Good.

The Foie Gras Brulee with Sour Cherry-Yuzu Marmalade was absolutely stunning – it will make it into 2008′s list of great dishes. The crust was tough while the cold foie inside was very creamy. The textural sensations were on par with the tastes; again, a wide range – the hard crunch of the shell, the ‘softer’ crunch of the brioche, and the creamy foie inside. The marmalade gave the dish just enough acidity. Excellent.

On paper, the Black Cod Steamed with Honsheimeji Mushrooms and Lemongrass Consomme sounded like it could hit that right note of subtleness with me. However, the dish was a bit bland. The fish was slightly over-cooked, preventing the texture from achieving that wonderful black cod silkiness. The lemon zest in the mushrooms perked up but nothing else popped. The lemongrass consomme lacked much flavor, despite being mixed with tomato water. Ok.

The Crispy Arctic Char, Miso-Potato Puree, and Granny Smith-Jalapeno Juice was a fantastic concept with some execution issues. Texture was front and center – crisped skin, the red chips, the fish, and the puree. The fish was not cooked correctly – the outside was overcooked while the inside was raw. Regardless, the taste sensations reminded one of the earlier dishes – upfront jalapeno and miso that gave way to the fish and apple. Good.

The Tangy Glazed Short Ribs, Crunchy Grits, and Herb Salad, no fault of the restaurant, were too much – I was full. The glaze was quite sweet but the herb salad was powerfully acidic and did a great job balancing out the richness of the ribs. The crunchy grits fulfilled the textural obligations of a Jean Georges dish.

There were a lot of desserts and I didn’t keep notes. However, I thought they were very good overall. They blended effortlessly into the meal – a sweet continuation of the savory courses. There were big tastes – tamarind ice cream and apple/dill sorbet – and textures – jicama noodles. I would probably order one less dish next time so I could enjoy dessert more.

Overall, I had a very enjoyable lunch. This time, I enjoyed the in-your-face flavors, so much that I missed them in the cod dish. For the price, I think every food lover should try Jean Georges for lunch. Jean George’s dining empire spans the globe, and much of his cuisine is ubiquitous, but the flagship restaurant offers a worthwhile experience.

- chuck

1 – This meal cost $149 with a $70 bottle of wine. That is a remarkable value.

2 – It is also worth nothing that I have the special asterisk next to my name in their computer. That symbol may, or may not, account for the quality of the meal.

  • stephen

    chuck, as I understood it, there are only two courses to lunch at JG. Did you just order more?

  • sygyzy

    That is an amazingly cheap meal. I really cannot believe it. It’s something you could do almost once a month, without it really needing to be a special occasion!

    How do you know about the asterisks and how do you get one?

  • ChuckEats

    stephen, the JG lunch menu reads “$28 for 2 courses, each additional plate $12″ – so i loaded up. if i were local, i’d stop in for the $28 lunch once a week without question. for that, you get 1 amuse, 2 dishes, macaroons, marshmellows, and chocolates.

    sygyzy, my guests at the last meal (ideas in food) are friends with johnny iuzzini. the transitive property works in fine dining too.

  • Aaron

    Glad you enjoyed your meal, Chuck. There’s no question that is the best value for the money in NYC, and frankly it’s the best value for the money I’ve seen anywhere. I personally didn’t much care for the texture of the bread in combination with that of the uni, but the flavors worked wonderfully. I’ve also had a few variations of the foie gras brulee (rhubarb/pineapple/szechuan peppercorn and cherry/pistachio come to mind) that you enjoyed so much, and I agree that it’s always fabulous. I’m always a fan of Iuzzini’s work. Really nice guy as well. Lastly, it looks like your desserts were:

    - Spiced Pumpkin Mousse, Gingerbread Spone, Crispy Cranberry
    - Pomegranate Sorbet with Fresh Pomegranate Seeds

    - Apple Confit, Pine Nut Sponge, Smoked Raisin, Tamarind Ice Cream
    - Granny Smith-Fennel Sorbet, Crispy and Candied Fennel


  • sygyzy


    Thanks for the insight. I love how they are known now by their blog name. It’s like their alter ego. HAHA.

  • ChuckEats

    aaron – you’re right about the desserts – just found my dessert menu.

  • Doug

    Lovely descriptions. The brioche looks excellent, as described.

  • Nick N

    Chuck ur the man.
    Lunch looks excellent. Talk about value
    check out my new blog

  • Marc Collins

    I was one of the chefs that dined with the Wandering Eater. I enjoyed your take on JG’s and although it is a great deal in town Eleven Madison Park has to be hands down the best lunch in New York. In some aspects it was better than my meal at Per Se. I enjoyed Per Se very much but for the money I’d rather have eaten several times at Eleven Madison. You need to come to Charleston, SC and dine some time. I’d like to know what you think of the scene here. We have a depth of great restaurants not found in a city of this size elsewhere. Have a great day and keep the blog rolling!

  • ChuckEats

    Thanks for the comments Marc. I’ve eaten at 11 Madison park twice (and Humm’s food thrice in San Francisco) and I feel he hasn’t progressed as a chef in four years. However, last year’s summer reports were astounding; if i make it back to NYC this summer, I will give 11 Mad a shot.

    Charleston – I have one night planned in June for McCrady’s, book-ended by two nights in ATL – friends vs food :)